Loading...
Skip to Main Content
Free US Shipping Over $60 | Free Exchanges and Returns
New
Trending
Themes
Popular Themes
Animals
Anime
Books
Cannabis
Cats
Christmas
Dogs
Feminista
Foodies
Memes
Nerdy
NSFW
Politics
Retro
Science
Space
Tarot Cards
Unicorns
Video Games
Witches
More...
Books
Fitness
Plants
Apparel
Apparel
Baby One Piece
Baseball Tees
Face Masks
Hoodies
Long Sleeve Tees
Neck Gaiters
Racerback Tanks
Socks
Sweatshirts
Tanks
Tees
V-Neck Tees
T-Shirts
Socks
Sweatshirts
Baseball Tees
Bags
Bags
Accessory Bags
Casual Totes
Pencil Pouches
Totes
Weekender Bags
Totes
Casual Totes
Weekender Bags
Accessory Bags
Coffee Mugs
Drinkware
All Mugs
Animal Pun Mugs
Nerdy Mugs
Sassy Mugs
Science Mugs
Sassy Mugs
Animal Pun Mugs
Nerdy Mugs
Science Mugs
Tech
Tech
Accessory Bags
AirPods Cases
iPhone Cases
Phone Cases
Laptop Stickers
Samsung Cases
Airpod Cases
Phone Cases
Stickers
Accessory Bags
Home
Home
Blankets & Throws
Garden Flags
Holiday Ornaments
Magnets
Pillows
Posters
Shower Curtain
Stickers
Tapestries
Towels
Welcome Mats
Garden Flag
Pillow
Poster
Blankets
Stationery
Stationery
Birthday Cards
Greeting Cards
Notebooks
Stickers
Notebooks
Stickers
Greeting Cards
Accessories
Accessories
Accessory Bags
AirPods Cases
Credit Card Skins
Magnets
Phone Cases
Pins
Stickers
Stickers
Pins
Accessory Bags
Phone Cases
Seasonal
Seasonal
Valentine Cards
Ornaments
Stockings
Valentine's Day
St. Patrick's Day
Easter
Mother's Day
Father's Day
Valentine's Day
St. Patrick's Day
Easter
Mother's Day
Sale
X
HOME
Account
New
Trending
Bestsellers
Sale
{{ link }}
{{ link }}
Stickers
Shipping
Contact Us
X
Back
{{ currentTitle }}
{{ name }}
X
{{flyoutData.product.title}}
${{flyoutData.pricing.promotion.price}}
${{flyoutData.pricing.base_price}}
Style:
{{flyoutData.inventory.inventory_style.description}}
Size:
{{flyoutData.inventory.inventory_size.size}}
Color:
{{flyoutData.inventory.inventory_color.description}}
Quantity:
{{ flyoutData.quantity }}
1 item was added to your cart.
Checkout
Sort
Filter
Sort
Most Relevant
Date Added (Newest)
Date Added (Oldest)
Most Relevant
Date Added (Newest)
Date Added (Oldest)
Filters
New
Trending
Product Types
Clothing (371)
unisex t-shirts
unisex long sleeve tees
womens t-shirts
kids t-shirts
Baseball Tees
V-Neck Tee Shirts
Racerback Tank Tops
Tank Tops
Baseball Tees
Sweatshirts
Hooded Sweatshirts
Baby One-Pieces
Coffee Mugs (81)
Pins (40)
Socks (36)
Pillows (29)
Totes (29)
Garden Flag (21)
Phone Cases (20)
Greeting Cards (17)
Die Cut Sticker (14)
Magnet (14)
Accordion Face Mask (10)
Flat Face Mask (10)
Ornament (10)
Casual Tote (9)
Notebook (9)
Weekender Totes (5)
Blankets (4)
Neck Gaiter (4)
Posters (4)
Popular Topics
Dungeons And Dragons
Nerds
D D
Dungeons
Critical Roll
Fantasy
Table Top Gaming
Tabletop Gaming
Cats
Critical Fail
Critical Hit
Dnd Memes
Monsters
Crit
Cryptids
D And D
Dm
Funny
Rpgs
Valentines Day Gifts
Critical Fail Pillows
Browse our collection of 29 Critical Fail Pillows . Most designs are also available on T-Shirts, Tank Tops, Racerbacks, Sweatshirts, Hoodies and other items. Designed and printed in the USA. 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed.
These DnD Products Are A Critical Must For Your Collection
Roll For Initiative With These Fun DnD Inspired Gifts
These Gifts Are For Anyone Who's A Huge Nerd
Dungeons And Dragons
Nerds
D D
Dungeons
Critical Roll
Fantasy
Table Top Gaming
Tabletop Gaming
Cats
Critical Fail
Critical Hit
Dnd Memes
Monsters
Crit
Cryptids
D And D
Dm
Funny
Rpgs
Valentines Day Gifts
{{ facet.human_readable_filter }}
{{ facet.human_readable_value }}
x
Sort
Most Relevant
Date Added (Newest)
Date Added (Oldest)
Most Relevant
Date Added (Newest)
Date Added (Oldest)
Filters
New
Trending
Product Types
Clothing (371)
unisex t-shirts
unisex long sleeve tees
womens t-shirts
kids t-shirts
Baseball Tees
V-Neck Tee Shirts
Racerback Tank Tops
Tank Tops
Baseball Tees
Sweatshirts
Hooded Sweatshirts
Baby One-Pieces
Coffee Mugs (81)
Pins (40)
Socks (36)
Pillows (29)
Totes (29)
Garden Flag (21)
Phone Cases (20)
Greeting Cards (17)
Die Cut Sticker (14)
Magnet (14)
Accordion Face Mask (10)
Flat Face Mask (10)
Ornament (10)
Casual Tote (9)
Notebook (9)
Weekender Totes (5)
Blankets (4)
Neck Gaiter (4)
Posters (4)
Popular Topics
Dungeons And Dragons
Nerds
D D
Dungeons
Critical Roll
Fantasy
Table Top Gaming
Tabletop Gaming
Cats
Critical Fail
Critical Hit
Dnd Memes
Monsters
Crit
Cryptids
D And D
Dm
Funny
Rpgs
Valentines Day Gifts
Failed a Save Against Sleep Pillow
OOP I failed a saving throw against sleep now I'm gonna take a critical nap BYE.
Critical Honk Pillow
It's a crit! Roll a critical honk with this funny, "Critical Honk" goose design. Perfect for being a dungeons and dragons nerd, critical hit, geese humor, goose puns, and roll playing games.
Let's Get Critical Dice Pillow
Inspired by the Olivia Newton-John's workout jam "Physical," get the best hits in your campaign with this design!
You're My Critical Crush DnD Valentine Pillow
Confession...you're my critical crush! Tell your crush how you feel with this cute, "You're My Critical Crush" Dungeons and Dragons inspired valentine. Perfect for DnD lovers and crushes!
When All Else Fails Take A Nap Pillow
When all else fails, and life has got you down just take a nap. Relax and chill out with this lazy and funny, nap pillow.
Tetris Cats Fail Pattern Pillow
This crazy pattern features the classic game of Tetris, but wait, the blocks are cats! Haven't you seen the cat photos online or your cat roll up into an impossible position? Where's the cat's head? Who knows? What we do know is that cats have no bones, which makes this Tetris pattern utterly hilarious. If you're a fan of video games, cats, and like a good laugh then this pillow is puuuurfect for you!
Dungeons and Dragons Yin Yang Pillow
Will you be a critical hit? Or a Critical Failure? The world of D&D cannot revolve without one or the other, so whichever you are, just know that you play a CRITICAL ROLL in the game.
Be My Bae-tyr Valentine Satyr Pillow
Flirt with bae like a horndogged-half-goat-person with this funny d&d and fantasy inspired satyr pun! Perfect for a nerdy Valentine day gift or setting the mood for your next campaign.
Be My Bae-tyr Valentine Satyr Pillow
Flirt with bae like a horndogged-half-goat-person with this funny d&d and fantasy inspired satyr pun! Perfect for a nerdy Valentine day gift or setting the mood for your next campaign.
If Nothing Goes Right Pillow Pillow
Stay motivated with this inspiring pillow. When all else fails, if nothing goes right, go left and keep on moving!
World's Okayest Dungeon Master Pillow
Ya know, it may not be the best campaign in the world but its not the worst. Flaunt your absolute, overwhelmingly medium adequacy with this funny geeky design depicting a d20 landing on a 10, marking the middle of the road performance check required for a totally serviceable, unremarkable dungeon master.
Cause of Death: Rolled a Nat 1 Pillow
Here lies my player character, cause of death? These very rude dice that gave me a natural 1 on my death saves. Make light of your bad luck with this nerdy design, perfect for any tabletop game night!
Snow Pillow Pillow
Celebrate the beauty of winter! Snowflakes come in all shapes and sizes, and no two are the same. They are nature's beautiful little crystalline baubles and they never fail to fill us with wonder. Perfect for the holidays.
I Can Lift 500+ Pounds (In D&D) Pillow
Listen buddy, don't mess with me I can lift 500+ pounds (in dnd). Show off your strength (in a role playing setting) and flex your beautiful muscles (that your wicked cool barbarian has) with this funny workout design that's perfect for the gym (and by the gym I mean this campaign's next session).
Dungeon Meowster Pillow
This Dungeon Meowster isn't Kittin' Around! There's no saving your pawlidin after failing your saving throws. What do you think he is, some kinda pussy cat?.... wait...
You Had One Job (Supreme Court) Pillow
You had ONE job... and you epically failed the people. Let this design speak for you with a modern take on a classic meme in response to the Supreme courts Roe V Wade ruling.
In Ruth We Trust Pillow
In Ruth We Trust! When all else in governments fail us feminists, we know at the very least, we've got the incredible Notorious Ruth Bader Ginsburg on our side to serve justice and notorious dissent. We love you, RBG.
Yep I'm Good Thanks Diver Pillow
Nah it's cool I feel good about life, doin' great. It's cool, I didn't feel like doing stuff today anyway. Sometimes life hands harpoons you in the chest and you run out of air as you sink to the bottom of the ocean, only to be eaten by a kraken. Contemplate your life and all the things outside of your control with this funny bad day diver pillow with a sarcastic phrase that says "Yep I'm good, thanks", perfect for failing to be an adult, dealing with problems, and hating mondays.
Nerdy Dads Build Character Pillow
It's a critical hit, having a nerdy dad builds character. Show off your love of your dad, being a dad, and DnD with this, "Nerdy Dads Build Character" dungeons and dragons inspired dad design!
Pumpkin Dice Pillow
Pumpkin spice and roll your dice! This set of dice is perfect for fall RPG fun! Yeah pumpkin spice is great, but show your DM this pumpkin dice design, and they'll be sure to ease up on your campaign...
This Mom Knows How to Party Pillow
Everyone knows mom rolls hella good on vibe checks cause her charisma is so dang high! Get some laughs this mothers day with this funny, nerdy mom joke, sure to be a critical success!
Yee Hawful Good Pillow
What's my character's alignment? YEEHAWFUL GOOD Y'ALL! Be the cowboy your party needs next campaign with this humorous western spin on lawful good, perfect for a game of Wagons & Dragons.
Roll For Romance Pillow
Initiate combat, er, romance, with this cute d20 featuring a CRITICAL HEART, which means a complete success on your romance rolls. Perfect for valentines day or your next table top adventure night!
I Cast Meowgic Missile Pillow
As a sorcerpurr, I use a spell slot and cast MEOWGIC MISSILE! Get downright charismatically cute with this adorable cat wizard design that's sure to be a critical hit with your adventuring party!
Yee Claw Hoardy Y'all Pillow
YEEEEEE CLAW! Hoardy Y'all! Wanna play some Dungeons and Wagons?! Bust out your boots and get to hoarding some gold with this funny cowboy dragon design sure to be a critical hit at your next campaign session!
(Doctor) Who You Gonna Call? Pillow
Who you gonna call? The Doctor, of course! Impress your buddies, whether you're at a convention or hanging out, with this sweet Doctor Who pillow! The Doctor can handle any situation, large or small, and failing that, you can just leave in the TARDIS.
You Kenku It Pillow
You KENKU it!! I believe in you! Get all nat 20's in your next campaign with this funny kenku design that's sure to be a critical success among your party members and your dungeon master!
Warrior Cats Pillow
Get a critical role for CLASSY with this cute nerdy cat design featuring a bunch of felines as various rpg classes- wizard, rogue, warrior, bard, ranger, and cleric cats! Perfect for any dungeon master looking to run a pawsitively adorable campaign!
Seven of Dice - D&D Tarot Pillow
This tarot reading is critical to your future. Role play your next reading with this, "Seven of Dice" D&D inspired tarot card design. A great design for D&D players, tarot readers, nerdy gifts, and lovers of Dungeons & Dragons! nerdy tarot tarot illustration palm reading d4 d6 d12 d20 d&d dice dungeons and dragons tarot.
{{product.fields.title}} {{product.mapped_type.human_readable}}
With Coupon {{ product.pricing.coupon.toUpperCase() }}
Prev
Page
1
of
1
Next
{{ loadProductsText }}
No More Results
Recently Viewed
×
Email Address:
Subscribe
;